According to McShay, Alabama quarterback Ty Simpson needs another collegiate season in Ty Simpson NFL Draft evaluation, citing accuracy concerns and five consecutive games with pocket fumbles. The draft expert maintains Simpson has NFL Prospect potential but requires additional development time.
Ty Simpson NFL Draft Decision Requires Development
McShay emphasized Simpson’s fundamental issues despite recognizing his Pro Potential. The Alabama Football quarterback’s accuracy deteriorates when his process is rushed, particularly on deep-ball attempts. Defenses have accumulated sufficient tape to disrupt Simpson’s timing, causing footwork problems that affect his precision.
“He needs to go back to school. I truly believe that. I’ve seen enough flaws—from the accuracy to when his process is rushed,” McShay explained.
The analyst noted Simpson’s exceptional processing abilities for someone with limited game experience, highlighting his pre-snap and post-snap recognition skills as NFL-caliber traits.
Oregon’s Quarterback Situation Impacts Class Strength
Dante Moore’s improved performance at Oregon complicates the 2025 NFL Draft quarterback landscape. McShay indicated that Moore isn’t ready for professional football despite recent strong play. The departure of offensive coordinator Will Stein removes a crucial development factor that could have influenced both quarterbacks’ decisions.
The current Quarterback NFL Draft Prospects class lacks elite options without Arch Manning, Shedeur Sanders, and potentially Simpson if he returns. Fernando Mendoza represents the primary first-round option in a relatively thin quarterback group for NFL Draft Rankings.
Declaration Deadline Approaching
Underclassmen face a January 15th deadline for Ty Simpson 2025 NFL Draft Decision declarations. Players participating in playoff games receive extensions, potentially pushing decisions to January 20th if Oregon reaches the national championship. McShay’s Scouting Report suggests Simpson possesses the arm strength, mobility, and intelligence for NFL success but requires additional refinement.
The timeline creates pressure for Alabama Quarterback NFL Draft Prospects and other underclassmen considering early entry into what appears to be a weaker quarterback Draft Position class.
McShay’s evaluation suggests Simpson’s Draft Stock benefits from additional development time at Alabama despite his clear NFL potential. For more coverage of quarterback prospects and expert analysis, visit Prospect-Radar.com.
